Page 1 of 1

HP Resolves Ink Cartridge Patent Infringement Dispute

Posted: Thu Jul 19, 2007 10:33 am
by Digital Puppy
HP Resolves Ink Cartridge Patent Infringement Dispute
PALO ALTO, Calif. -- Jul. 19, 2007 HP (NYSE:HPQ) today announced that it has resolved a patent infringement lawsuit against German-based InkTec GmbH Zentrale and PCE Group regarding inks used in the refilling of certain HP inkjet cartridges.

The settlement also included resolution with Korea-based InkTec Ltd., the manufacturer and distributor of the infringing products.

As part of the settlement, both InkTec entities and the PCE Group acknowledged the validity of the HP patents in suit and admitted to infringement. In addition, they agreed to pay HP an undisclosed sum, to stop selling infringing inks in Germany and other countries where such patents are held, and to withdraw infringing products from the market in those countries.

In October 2006, HP filed suit against InkTec GmbH Zentrale and the PCE Group in the District Court of Dusseldorf, Germany, after HP discovered that certain ink refill kits sold under the InkTec brand and distributed by InkTec and PCE Group contained infringing ink. HP asserted two patents relating to ink formulations and specifically accused InkTec refill kits used for refilling certain HP inkjet printer cartridges.

"HP will continue to invest in technology that benefits customers and to vigorously protect this investment," said Michael Hoffmann, senior vice president, Supplies, Imaging and Printing Group, HP. "We're pleased to have resolved this matter quickly without extensive litigation and will continue to monitor InkTec and others for possible patent infringement as part of our ongoing worldwide testing and enforcement efforts."

About HP

HP focuses on simplifying technology experiences for all of its customers - from individual consumers to the largest businesses. With a portfolio that spans printing, personal computing, software, services and IT infrastructure, HP is among the world's largest IT companies, with revenue totaling $97.1 billion for the four fiscal quarters ended April 30, 2007. More information about HP is available at http://www.hp.com.

Re: HP Resolves Ink Cartridge Patent Infringement Dispute

Posted: Fri Jul 20, 2007 6:15 am
by KnightRid
Frickin money hungry bastards

OK, now let me tell you what I REALLY think.

Printer manufacturerers have gotten used to selling cheap printers (which are CHEAP to produce also) and then selling ink for ridiculous fees. I think this has to stop. There is no reason that they need to charge $30 a cartridge when you can get a refilled one for $5! Why does everyone just sit down and take it in the rear without saying anything about this procedure? I have been refilling my cartridges for YEARS and I will continue to do so until they make it impossible, at which time, I will quit printing.

Toner cartridges for a color laser at $150 each??!!!?? that would be $600 to buy all new toner, when the printer only cost you around $400!

Take a stand and tell HP to shove their ink where the sun dont shine. Also tell LExmark, Epson, Canon, etc :)

Mike

I think this is the one area in the computer industry that there has yet to be a fix for. We have cheap video cards, components, etc, but no cheap printer with CHEAP ink. WHY? If the generic ink people can produce a cartridge for $5, I am damn sure the major comapnies could do it even cheaper. ARGH

:evil: kinda like the oil industry only with ink...sad sad world