Unfortunately my budget has been severely reduced.  My fiance has decided that a better use of the money would be to purchase a new bed.  So, that's what we're doing.  We're buying a 
TempurPedic.  And I now only have a budget of $500 to make something better than what I own.  I can recycle my OS, HDDs, and DVDR, but that's about it.  I could recycle my case, but I don't want to as the airflow is crap, and I never really like it to begin with.  I could probably recycle my PSU, but I would imagine that due to it's age (4+ years) it's less efficient than modern PSUs, so the savings I might gain recycling it would be outweighed by the savings in electricity that I would gain buying a new one.
SO, here is my new list.  I've mostly just picked what I could afford, with an eye towards upgrading in the future.
Case 
Cooler Master
MOBO 
Gigabyte GA-P35-S3G
CPU 
Intel E2160 Allendale
PSU 
XIGMATEK 650
RAM 
Super Talent 2GB
Video 
EVGA 8600 GT 1 GB
and a 
ZeroTherm Nirvana (hope it fits in that case)
So ... there it is.  Plan "B"
Well, we'll see how it goes.